Our Conservative government has recently announced several changes to Canada’s drug laws. Boiled down, these changes will more closely align Canadian law with the Draconian American version. As with the War on Drugs south of the border, punishment and enforcement are highlighted.
To be fair, the changes do allow for some portion of the new cash to be spent on harm-reducing measures such as rehabilitation, treatment and education. But punishment is being ramped up, despite overwhelming evidence (the entire US system as an example) that these tactics simply don’t work.
What continues to trouble many activists (including this one), however, is how readily we seem to ignore the societal issues behind drug addiction and abuse.
In the 1970’s, the general public was discussing the Skinner box. Part of of a series of experiments using this apparatus placed a lab animal in a tiny cage with a lever that, when pressed, injected the animal with a drug. Trials showed that animals willingly enslaved themselves to recreational drugs such as heroin and cocaine.
Presented with this evidence, Dr. Bruce Alexander and his team of scientists ran a different set of tests: the Rat Park. This new attempt involved rats living in more natural settings: colonies instead of isolation; large enclosures instead of cages; nesting materials and toys instead of electrified floors and glass walls. They were fed well and for water were offered a choice between a normal water bottle and one filled laced with morphine.
The rats quickly learned the difference and avoided the morphine entirely. When the morphine water was sweetened they continued to ignore it. When the unlaced batch was removed for two months, they became chemically dependent upon the drug, only to have the clean water re-introduced. The rats willingly went through withdrawal symptoms and switched back to the unlaced water.
A remarkable aversion to drug addiction by a simple creature. This aligns with evidence of human addicts who, when their life circumstances change, will give up something they had previously depended upon. While American soldiers used heroin rampantly during the Vietnam War, usage and addiction rates plummeted when they returned home. Hospital patients who became addicted to morphine due to chronic pain issues have shown almost universal willingness and ability to quit as soon as they are better.
These examples (along with others) hint toward a conclusion that, when considered seriously, seems logical: drug addiction is a result of environmental pressures. It is not, as our drug policy reflects, a result of simple exposure to a drug.
War, poverty, boredom, stress - all things people would love to escape. Escape - the very thing drugs provide. Does it not follow that by alleviating these societal pressures the dependency on drugs will be lifted?
Unfortunately this line of thinking runs up against a seemingly impenetrable wall: the entirety of our anti-drug propaganda and capitalist society as a whole. The massive majority of research on addiction is examined as if it is a medical or chemical issue. Dr. Alexander describes it as such:
“There’s a mainstream that has all the money, sponsored primarily by the American government. Those researchers truly believe that they’re dealing with a brain disease, and that they will discover the pill that will solve the problem.” - From the Walrus, here.
Furthermore, our society is built around stress and makes money off people’s need to escape. We hate our jobs so we drink, shop, or smoke (all legal) like crazy to forget about it. We even become addicted to work to avoid the home life, or lack thereof, we’ve created for ourselves. We grow addicted to our religious beliefs to dodge feelings of emptiness, uselessness and meaninglessness. We gamble because we’re bored and poor, hoping to be the one miracle case that wins the lottery or beats the casino.
We’re all addicts of some kind, but our governments have chosen for us which drugs are good and which aren’t. Prohibition simply romanticizes another outlet, another means of escape. People who aren’t willing to break the law find other drugs to alleviate their dissatisfaction with their lives.
Ultimately we need to address the fact that our civilization makes a large portion of the population miserable. People can’t stop shopping and don’t know why, despite studies that show the pleasure of a new purchase mimics the brain’s response to drugs and alcohol. It is their drug, and they become addicted for the same reason as any alcoholic.
It’s time we asked ourselves some tough questions:
What can we change about the way our societies work that will eliminate this unhappiness and the addictions it creates? How different are our lives from the rats in the Skinner box? Aren’t we all just pushing levers for treats?
There is something fundamentally wrong with Western civilization. First one to figure it out gets a candy.
Share This